Key Pizza in Hammond

Great pizza! Tasted fresh, loaded with toppings, great crust and delivered hot! Very reasonable price..will be our pizza place from now on!

As I sit here eating my sausage stuffed crust I wonder where the sauce is....minus the absence of sauce it's a great pizza. Would've given 4 stars otherwise. Definitely ask for extra sauce. Quick delivery, friendly people.

I rarely have any issues with this place, and if a problem occurs they fix it without hassle. The workers are friendly, and the food is fantastic! Great pizza place, great prices!

My husband grew up on their pizza. Me personally not a fan. Just didn't enjoy the taste. At least my husband enjoyed it. There was absolutely nothing wrong with the order, just as I said I was not a fan. You may like it. Just I didn't.

Woman was not pleasant pizza was terrible peppers on the beef sandwich were not cooked waste of my money

This place is amazing I ordered online and something went wrong nd I didnt get my order I waited a few before I eventually realized something must be wrong since quite awhile had passed I call I find out they are now closed... Somehow my order got mixed up somehow but the guy who answered the phone assured me that he would be personally staying and making my order nd bringing it to me he didnt have too do that he could of apologized nd refunded me my money but said no I dont want you not getting your food... I usually order from a different place but I will definitely be becoming a regular here... That is impeccable customer service and I truly appreciate you guys...

I ordered a deep dish pizza at 8:07!! It is 9:44 and this restaurant is now CLOSED & NOT answering the phone !!!! I been calling since 9:00 !!!! I paid 30 dollars for this pizza that I did NOT receive! I will be going to this restaurant tomorrow !!!

Key Pizza? Best thin crust in the area. Flavor of sauce is great, right amount of cheese...they use the crumbled sausage. Friendly staff. Prices are fair. Highly recommend.

Called to order 2 large 2 topping pizzas. One pizza was 1/2 pepperoni with pineapple and other half pepperoni with bacon. The other pizza was 1/2 sausage with mushroom and the other 1/2 sausage with pepperoni. They said 40 minutes for pick-up. 1 hour and 15 minutes later, I finally get my order. This was absolutely uncalled for. Received a free 2 liter and $5 off and a coupon for $5 off the next 2 times I order. Didn't feel that was enough. Not sure I would ever order from here again.

Deep dish is the best great people working there

Worker was nice and bright my order to my car. Great pizza

Good pizza but the last time I ordered from here, they gave me crumbled sausage which ruined the whole pizza. Just be aware that you need to specify chunk sausage in order not to get the crumbled garbage.

I've been ordering from keys pizza a while now but as of recently i have tried the online ordering system .. Where i make the order they take the Money immediately and then they call to explain to you that there out of some of the things you Ordered. Last time it was Chunk sausage and this time it was wings ... They offer a refund but it takes 3-5 days to return back to your card..I would not recommend anyone to use the online ordering system either go in or call..a total inconvenience.

Worst pizza I have ever had in my entire life.

Amazing food and even better service

Great pizza!

We ordered two pizzas online, a thin crust and a stuffed crust pizza. Excellent crust quality on both pizzas and way better than any chain pizza place. Parking is tricky for pick-up orders, but the price and quality is worth it.

My boyfriend and I ordered a pizza for pickup. They quoted us a 40 minute wait. When we went in to pick up our pizza they seemed confused. We noticed a burnt pizza being pulled out of the oven. Not sure if that was ours or if they forgot to make ours. Anyways instead of telling us their mistake, they didn’t say anything at all and proceeded to make our pizza while we were standing there. After waiting another 15 minutes and expecting them to say something to us, which they never did, we left. They never called or anything. Unbelievable. The only reason I gave them 3 stars instead of 1 is because I’ve had their pizza and it’s very good. Service however, is another story. Did management change??

Order a pizza, drove 40 minutes round trip to pick up... but was not what we ordered at all. Called them, and They said they must have misunderstood our order. Very disappointing when you use to provide great pizza and service.

Best pizza place in town. I get the pizza every time!! The staff is extremely friendly, and are always available to help. It gets busy sometimes but it's worth the go. I come here once a week just to enjoy the food. I would prefer this pizza over any other pizza place in the world. I highly recommend this place for everyone!

I asked for a deep dish pizza. I got a stuffed pizza. There is no excuse for confusing my order with a stuffed pizza. The person on the phone didn't understand the difference. Unacceptable. for Chicagoland. This restaurant refuses to deliver to Gary. This is an insulting policy as they are 3 minutes from the border of Hammond/Gary. It's time Key pizza improved it's business. Maybe this review will encourage them.Windy City II down the road is a much better choice. They at least know what a deep dish pizza is.

I can’t speak for the food but I was on hold twice for 10 to 15 min each back to back with a rude voice...I’ll take my business elsewhere.

Be eating here over 25 years the best

Awesome pizza.

Everything is delicious. The pizza is great, the sandwiches are awesome, and wings are really good.

A coworker ordered from here and it was really good. I'm not a fan of pizza in Indiana, but this was really good. Love the sausage stuffed pizza. Trying the Supreme stuffed today.

Good tasting pizza

If I could give it no stars I would..everytime I order from here they get my order wrong..The last visit I had they messed up one of my sandwiches and took it back to be fixed just to get home and realize they messed it up again..i was contacted by management and told i was being given a credit but when i tried to use it the next visit i was told it couldnt be honored cuz there was no record of it..just horrible service all around

Great pizza, sandwiches, wings, and customer service! Our favorite is the stuffed pizza.

Great pizza fair price been going there for years

This is the only place that I believe has the best stuffed pizza ever!!

Bad. Service....

Haven't had Key Pizza in 17 yrs. Just moved back from VA and decided to order and try it out. I know ownership changed, sauce had no taste and pizza overcooked. I will eat House of Pizza from now on. Fabulous pizza their everybody!

The small pizzas are cut like a pie, ( as they should be). The pizzas taste great. I have already been back!

The ready made pizza was delicious the service was friendly and the environment is very laid back. Great lunch spot and great prices.

The wing was horrible. And the cheese pizza was ok but I was better off getting a frozen Jacks pizza

The weekend evening staff are awesome. The pizzas are delicious. Especially the crumbled sausage and pepperoni. My advice to people who have called ahead and were given the wrong order is to make sure that your cell phone cover isn’t to blame. Because when I get on my phone and people can’t clearly hear me is because of the phone case. So back to the review, it’s the best pizza in all of Hammond Indiana and most parts of Chicago suburbs as well.

I ordered an large cheese pizza with bbq wings. The Pizza was pretty good, the sauce and cheese were amazing but it's something a little off about the crust. The wings were terrible not even being dramatic. Like really how are these prepared? Skin is super soft like they boil them and the bbq sauce is really bad. Lol just don't do the wings at all even if offered for free. Also the woman that answers the phone is a lil rude. Update: called to let them know about the wings and they told me "No one ever called in about the wings so. ." Unprofessional, tho they did offer to replace them after I said I would come show them the wings. Really wouldn't recommend to a friend or foe.

Always great food and service.

Just ordered for the first time and it won’t be my last! Beside the crust being slightly burned it was delicious and it had a similar taste to my homemade pizza!

Best beef around Chicago 💪🏻

I have never written a review until today. Recently moved to Hammond and thought I'd try a new pizza place since Beggars isn't close. BOTH times I tried, my order wasn't correct. I would've let it slide if the pizza was good, but it's not. You get what you pay for. Spend the extra money and get a quality pizza.

Man o man!!!❤ driven by this place for years and did I ever waste a lot of effort looking for great pizza in the meantime. Just fantastic. Great crust delicious sauce excellent sausage and piled with cheese cooked in a REAL oven .......best "find" for me clos3 to home in years. A sure repeat unDOUBTedly. Five stars⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Ordered six pizzas and 5 were ice cold. Made to far in advance while waiting for the lady one to finish. $152.00 should demand better attention and quality.

Come from Alabama to get a good pizza and the servers are not friendly at all.

I've been going to Key pizza for years and it has never changed. They have delicious pizza and I recommend getting the 'stuffed crust' or 'fold over crust' which basically makes the end of each slice of pizza like you have a calzone! the crust folds over some of your pizza ingredients and makes it so much more interesting than an average pizza slice. Their cheese has a greasy salty flavor and I mean that in the best way possible, it really is delicious gooey goodness. The sauce is great. And they offer a huuuuuuge pizza,which is impressive.I love Key!

Love their pizza and very hot

We were waiting for ten minutes and no one took our order. One woman just stared at us. Went to colombia gyros instead.

I've been going here since the late 80s. Quality hasn't changed. Excellent pizza, and they are always correct on my order.

Loved it & now they have keto pizza! Yes!!